Response: Three men, one choice

New Girl 

Paul Gunslinger is the man on New Girl that Jess is attracted too by looks. They are almost the exact same person and although they joke and tease a lot they do not end up with each other. Jess actually cares a lot about him but not enough to stay with him. However I don't think he's like Jody at all I just think he's the guy that she is attracted to because he is different and looks good. 

Dermot Mulroney is the man that looks good on paper. A successful, accomplished business man that is a lot older than Jess. Although right now they are in a really good place with their relationship he is the most like Jody because he is older and sometime has the tendency to speak down to Jess. So I don't think he's like Logan because he actually can connect with Jess. 

Nick Miller is the real guy. (In my opinion) Anyone that watches New Girl can see that Jess and Nick really have something. They are both 100% themselves with each other. In other relationships Jess tends to act differently to make the man happy but with Nick she doesn't have too. Sure, they aren't actually in a relationship (yet) but I believe that Nick is most like Teacake because of their natural, teasing, (HOPEFULLY loving in the future) relationship. For right now in the show they are just the best friends that should be together. 

The main difference between Janie and Jess is that Jess genuinely cares for all of these guys. Also, the guy that looks good doesn't necessarily compare to Jody and the guy that looks good on paper isn't necessarily like Logan.